Eh, I’m not sure what I was expecting really.

So, rather than adapt the script for audio, they seem to have literally just got the actors to read out the script and put some sound effects around it. Which doesn’t sound all that bad, but you get almost no information about what’s happening from the script alone, so we have to guess and assume a lot and it’s all a little lacking really. It’s like watching TV with your back to the set. The story itself is lacklustre but fine, but the performances are exemplary as normal. I shan’t bother with any more of this range I think if they’re all gonna be like this; it really is a little difficult to follow and lacking in polish

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Nothing to see here

What could have made this a 4 or 5-star listening experience for you?

An actual story suitably adapted for audio.
Although there are references in the commentary to an actual script, the play comes across as something in the ideas stage - "Let's have the Toy Maker from an old William Hartnell story return to confront Colin Baker's Doctor and Peri in Blackpool" - and that's it.

What will your next listen be?

I did buy the complete set of missing stories from a cancelled season of 1980s Doctor Who, of which this is the first. I'm kind of regretting it now...
I'll give them a chance, but it may be the end for my Big Finish buying. There's too much good stuff out there for Big Finish to be complacent any more.

How did the narrator detract from the book?

If I recall correctly, in the early days of Big Finish, they stubbornly declared their plays were not "talking books" and so refused to feature a narrator. (They have since featured narrators in their Companion Chronicle plays, to good effect.)
The alternative to having a narrator is to have the scene described in the dialogue. This can work when the play is conceived of as an audio play in the first place, though in science fiction this expository dialogue often comes across as contrived and intrusive, especially during the action scenes.
The climax of this play is a lot of noises and people shouting at each other. The Doctor wins the day somehow - I've no idea how. It's like watching TV with sound but no picture.
Afterwards I did a search for other people's reviews of this story because I was worried I was the only one who didn't have a clue what was going on. One reviewer had listened to it several times and still had no idea.

If you could play editor, what scene or scenes would you have cut from Doctor Who - The Lost Stories - The Nightmare Fair?

If anything, I'd be adding scenes.
As it stands, we've got people running around a fair, other people locked in a cell, the Doctor up to something (no idea what) and some guns going off.

Any additional comments?

The only reason I am not asking for my credit back is because I like to keep my collections complete.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

2 people found this helpful