one of the best books I've read

this was a recommendation from a TV book programme, so I came with no real expectations other than the thanks the host gave the person who had made the recommendation seemed heartfelt and I thought "Might be good/interesting. The story unfolds within the protagonist's head much of the time, giving a wonderful perspective on internal fantasies, young love and insecurities without ever being maudlin, despite some troubling emotions. it spoke to me in a way I am unable to express as I do not possess the literary acumen. I don't really want to say anything about the plot other than she experiences nascent feelings for a number of her neighbours and when away from home a fellow student (who happens to be female, which given it was written in the 1920's I found interesting in the casual way this was addressed). the book essentially takes one on a journey from adolescence to adulthood and was written beautifully

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Youth, not so golden.

I first read this novel when I was fifteen and loved it. It expressed for me so accurately the intensity and self absorption of adolescence, the agony and the ecstasy . Now , in old age , oh dear, there is little to admire in the characters. Entitled , selfish , unhappy and unkind to each other.
I still love Rosamond Lehmann’s description of the garden....

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

3 people found this helpful

Best for young people

Any additional comments?

I should have liked this book much better in my teens when I might have had more patience with the main character. She really is quite tiresome (which, of course, she is not meant to be). Everything circles around herself, and only what she can't have seems important to her. She takes no real interest in others - at least not if they are "common" - with the exception of the two people she is obsessed by and perhaps in love with. In a way, you must pity Judith as well. She has been brought up by a mother who seems to be indifferent to her as a person. When Judith is deeply unhappy, all her mother can do for her is to go shopping. New outfits are the best comfort she can think of - and Judith seems to be grateful. No wonder, perhaps, that she is emotionally confused. The novel is beautifully written and Jenny Agutter's performance is excellent. I appreciate that she does not try to act, giving different voices to the characters. Some narrators do - and the result is seldom a success.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

5 people found this helpful