Is the comic book community sabotaging itself? In this episode of the 4Outsiders Comics Podcast, we dive headfirst into one of the most contentious topics in fandom: gatekeeping, creator harassment, and whether fans are their own worst enemy. We share our personal experiences and debate if protecting the art form has turned into toxic behaviour.

Before that, we deliver our unfiltered reviews of this week's most talked-about comics. We start with a deep-dive into Dan Slott's Superman Unlimited #2. Does Superman's new 'golden form' break the character, or is it a bold new direction? We analyse the 'kryptonite Wakanda' and what feels like a Marvel-style approach to the Man of Steel.

Next, we tackle Jonathan Hickman's Avengers vs. Aliens. After a huge build-up, did the finale feel rushed? We discuss the missed opportunities with Mr. Sinister, the Intergalactic Empire of Wakanda, and whether this crossover lived up to its potential. Finally, we review a hidden gem: James Tynion IV's Exquisite Corpses from Image Comics, a dark and gritty story that feels like The Purge for the super-rich.

Join us for a passionate discussion on the best and worst of modern comics and the community that surrounds them. Let us know your thoughts in the comments!

We've had our say, but what do you think? Are comic fans their own worst enemy, or is gatekeeping necessary? Head down to the comments section on YouTube or Spotify and let us know your thoughts. Do you agree with us, disagree, or have a take from out of left field? We want to hear it.

(Podcast brought to you by Skylarking Media Inc.)Show Notes

• (00:00) Introduction: The crew assembles to discuss the latest in comics, minus one co-host who is humorously "imprisoned in Latvia".
• (01:39) Comic Review: Superman Unlimited #2: The team gives a scathing review of Dan Slott's second issue. Key discussion points include the "shock jock" writing style, the absurd concept of a kryptonite-based nation, and the controversial new 'golden form' power that makes Superman immune to his core weakness for 200 seconds.
• (17:40) Comic Review: Avengers vs. Aliens #4: A deep-dive into the finale of Jonathan Hickman's mini-series. The hosts express disappointment with the rushed ending, the perversion of established characters like the Hulk, and the many seeded ideas that were never explored.
• (34:45) Comic Review: Exquisite Corpses #2: A positive review of the James Tynion IV and Michael Walsh horror series. The premise of a "battle royale" orchestrated by America's richest families is explored, praising its fun concept and gritty art.
• (41:58) Main Topic: Are Comic Fans Their Own Worst Enemy?: The central discussion begins. The hosts debate the pros and cons of gatekeeping, the impact of social media outrage on the industry, creator harassment, and whether the community is welcoming to new readers.
• (1:08:28) Housekeeping & Outro: How to find the podcast, support the show, and what's coming up next week.

Summary

In this episode of the Four Outsiders Comics Podcast, the hosts engage in a lively discussion about their recent comic book reads, including Supergirl #2, New Avengers, and the Death of Silver Surfer. They explore themes of identity, representation, and the evolution of characters in the comic book world. The conversation highlights the importance of storytelling and art in comics, while also reflecting on the cultural impact of these narratives. The hosts share their insights and opinions, making for an entertaining and informative episode for comic book enthusiasts. In this engaging conversation, the speakers explore various themes in literature and comics, focusing on character development, the significance of representation, and the evolution of beloved characters like Tim Drake and Miles Morales. They discuss the emotional connections readers have with characters, the impact of storytelling, and the challenges faced by writers in modern narratives. The conversation also touches on the importance of cultural representation in comics, particularly through works like Synth Squad, and the complexities of character arcs in the DC universe.

Chapters

00:00 Introduction to the Podcast and Hosts

00:00 Cold Open

01:36 Introduction

05:21 Weekly Reads: Supergirl #2 Review

11:19 Discussion on Supergirl's Character and Themes

16:15 Bucky Barnes and the New Avengers

25:59 The Death of Silver Surfer: A Philosophical Journey

38:49 Caricatures of Wealth and Power

41:48 The Silver Surfer's Journey

46:19 Spider-Man's New Adventures

54:31 Marvel's Cosmic and Terrestrial Conflicts

01:05:58 Introducing Sim Squad: A Caribbean Sci-Fi Adventure

01:11:23 Character Development and Emotional Depth in Storytelling

01:14:25 Art and Dialogue in Caribbean Comics

01:14:46 The Problem with Tim Drake: A Deep Dive

01:15:29 The Evolution of Robin: Perspectives on Tim Drake

01:20:35 Fandom and Character Attachment: The Case of Tim Drake

01:31:03 The Future of Tim Drake and the Batman Legacy

Keywords

comics, podcast, Supergirl, New Avengers, Silver Surfer, Spider-Man, graphic novels, comic book reviews, superhero stories, comic book culture, literature, comics, Miles Morales, Anansi, Ares, Deadpool, Synth Squad, Tim Drake, DC Comics, character development

Summary

In this episode of the 4 Outsiders Comics Podcast, the hosts delve into the ongoing debate of storytelling styles in comics, contrasting finite tales with ongoing series. They discuss the pros and cons of each approach, the impact of popularity on comic series, and the role of editorial influence in shaping narratives. The conversation also touches on character development, audience expectations, and the importance of narrative integrity.

The hosts review the comic 'Bridgeland' and share their thoughts on recent comic releases, including a new Superman series by Dan Slott, ultimately reflecting on the future of comic storytelling. In this conversation, the speakers delve into various themes surrounding comic book narratives, particularly focusing on Superman's portrayal, the overuse of Kryptonite, and the challenges faced by writers transitioning between Marvel and DC. They also discuss the latest issues of Moon Knight, the state of the comic book industry, and the cultural implications of manga versus Western comics. The dialogue highlights the need for a deeper understanding and appreciation of both mediums, as well as the importance of nurturing new talent in the comic book industry.

Chapters

00:00 Introduction to the Podcast and Hosts

00:01 Cold Open

00:21 Disclaimer & Theme

01:16 Hosts Intro

03:00 Weekly Picks

01:00:09 Bridgeland Inquisition

01:15:29 Main Topic

01:51:14 Remembering Peter David

02:19:02 Housekeeping & Wrap

02:20:40 Post Credits Chat