Great tale, let down by 1 terrible narrator

Great story, partially ruined by the painfully overdramatic and shrill narration of Lyria. Please recast!

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

12 people found this helpful

unexpectedly brilliant

Normally, the forth book of a trilogy spirals downwards towards dull, repetitive and an afterthought. (Think Dune). This book I found excellent. The characters remained in character. The story twisted and kept up the standard set by the first three books. It's a win for the author as I now need to listen to the next one like really quickly. Oh, as for the narration yep could be better but was too mesmerised by the story to care.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Great book, one big minus!

I'll echo what others have already said, the chap whom reads as Lysander is truly awful and detracts from what is otherwise a great story. It's almost as if he got paid up front and just wants to get the job done as soon as possible. That being said, this book is definitely worth downloading if you're a fan of the trilogy and want more. The new characters voiced by the other two narrators are excellent and is only slightly down on excitement from the original series.
I'm going to get straight into the next book as I am desperate to know how it all ends and then perhaps I can obsess about another book for a while!!!

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Superb addition to the saga

Was worried when I had seen the trilogy had been continued, but delighted with the instalment. Change of perspective with views from new characters directly adds another great layer, but the world building and the balance of epic scope to fantastic detail immerses you in the story throughout. Well worth a listen.
Beautifully performs by the 4 voice actors to bring each perspective to life.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Oh no! Multiple narrators ruined a great book!

I’ve been avidly listening to the series, great original narrator who stays on Darrow’s story, but the other three are killing it. I’ve gone looking for other books, (I’m so sorry, it’s you not me) even though I’m only a few chapters in, because I can’t hear the story as I could before through the weirdly flat, or over-the-top, or terrible at accents narrators. Who casts this so badly when it was bloody damn great before? And I know the writing is good, I can just about hear it, but it’s like food I love with either too much spice, too little salt, or just some wrong flavour. I hope you can make it through, I might come back for portions between other more satisfying meals.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Gory damn good

I was sceptical at first with the switch to multiple narrators and splintering storyline. But it works beautifully. Each story is gripping and essential. Each voice instantly flipping the character and story. So gory damn good.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Incredible

What can I say about these books? They are so immersive and continue to amaze me and enthral me. The characters and the stories are just fantastic. I’ll be so sad when the series ends

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Worthy sequel to a great sci-fi series!

I'll not say too much about the plot or story of Iron Gold but will say that I felt like it was a worthy sequel to the original Red Rising trilogy and that I felt the 10 year time jump and expanded POV cast did more to enhance the story than damage it. I love Darrow but I warmed to a few of the new characters and felt like they offered a different perspective on things which in turn gave the world a bit more depth to it.

Pierce Brown really is my sort of author. His writing is highly engaging and has a beautifully melancholic and poetic feel to it. His books are always intense and exciting and really drag me through the emotional ringer from start to finish. It is great when you find a book where you find the story super exciting and can emotionally engage with the characters and happenings.

On to the important stuff: Recorded Books decision to bring in three additional narrators!

I had some serious concerns going into Iron Gold when I heard that Recorded Books had decided to limit Tim Gerard Reynolds role in the book by brining in three new narrators to voice the three new POV's. The only positive was that they had retained TGR for the Darrow POV segments. I'm still puzzled by why they thought this was a good idea as TGR is one of the best narrators out there and his performance of the original Red Rising was fantastic. One of the best performances of any audio I've ever heard (and I've listened to hundreds of audios over the years!). The guy was so good he enhanced the quality of an already great story with his ability to convey emotion with his voice and his excellent voice acting.

It goes without saying that TGR's Darrow POV section of Iron Gold were as fantastic as one would expect. His take on Apollonius was stand out good and worthy of praise!

So how did the new narrators get on? They were a bit of a mixed bag.

John Curless - He did the Ephraim POV segments and I thought he was fantastic. Almost as good as TGR with his ability to convey emotions and he really got the tone and humour of the story. If he had a flaw it was that his character voices, while pretty good, were just not quite as good as TGR's. Still, he gets the thumbs up from me and I'll be happy to listen to more books he narrates in the future.

Aedin Moloney - She voiced the Lyria POV segments. I felt like she did an decent job. I took a bit of time to get used to her strong Irish accent and her dramatic style but once I did I warmed to her quickly. She struggled a little with the set voices and accents of the established characters but seemed to get the tone of the story and was also quite good at conveying emotion with her voice.

Julian Elfer - The guy voiced the Lysander bits of the story. I felt like he was the real weak link and the only narrator not up to the job. He was pretty awful. The only good thing he had going for him was that he was well-spoken and his voice was a great fit for an upper class Gold. The problem is that he was a poor voice actor and just read everything in a monotone. He even failed to get the humour which sounded decidedly off and stilted via his poorly timed delivery. He was also not great with the dialogue in general. It was often tough to figure out which characters were speaking!

At least the production by Recorded Books was not awful. To their credit they had the new narrators retain the accents used by TGR in the original RR trilogy. It is a minor thing but really makes a difference as it helps with consistency.

I feel like this would have been better if they had just stuck with TGR as the narrator for the whole book but that the additional narrators did not overly hurt my enjoyment of the audio as two of them were good and only Elfer was not up to the job.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

39 people found this helpful

haven't finished but...

the narrator for lyria is totally rubbish. the accent is so fake and the high pitch of her child's voice is like nails on a black board. I haven't finished reading but I can already tell this is going to be a slog.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

1 person found this helpful

Another fabulous chapter in the series

Another wonderful tale of inter-planetary skullduggery. Not a fan of two of the narrators (Lysander - too flat, Lyria - too highly strung), doesn’t spoil the overall delivery too much though so no harm done. If you love these books, this is an essential addition.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!